Design Edge Canada Website of the Year - Canadian Business Press
News
27 November 2009
Subplot executes redesign for Vancouver ERT
VANCOUVER—The mission, if Subplot chose to accept it, was to redesign the logo for Vancouver’s Emergency Response Team. Not only did they take on the challenge, says Matthew Clark, co-principal at Subplot, but they did it for no charge. “We offered to do it pro bono after they approached us so they wouldn’t have any costs at all and then would have money left over to execute the campaign,” he says. “We have found that it’s a problem if we give people a discount and then they don’t have money to use on the campaign.”
 
 
tktktk
The new font was hand drawn

The objective of the redesign was to make its logo accurately represent the group. “The old logo looked strangely like a sports team logo that featured a large machine gun,” says Clark. “It was both inappropriately sports-looking and very violent.”
 
Taking the emphasis away from the weapon, Clark wanted the new logo to represent the men and women on the team. “The officers in the new logo are completely silhouetted in black, which is reflective of their uniforms. We had a great photo shoot to get that shot. A couple of officers came into the office in full uniform pointing their guns at the wall while we took photos of them. That was quite fun and a little scary.” Contact: Subplot.com
— Val Maloney
1. Maggie
1 December 2009 at 10:04 AM
Is it just me or does it just look like the officer crouching is setting up to shoot the other officer in the back?

thats the first thing I see. Not too keen.
2. Hal
1 December 2009 at 11:21 AM
I hate to say it but even though the old logo is a tad dated and has a bit too much focus on the hardware... in my opinion was a much stronger option. The new logo looks rather lacking in effort, the silhouettes look like clip art and indeed the composition appears as though the crouching officer aiming at the other officers butt... I don't see this as an improvement at all.
3. yashar
1 December 2009 at 11:54 AM
Just because you do something pro bono doesn’t mean you shouldn’t put as much effort into a job as if you were being paid for it. The first logo looked like a frustrated baseball fan designed it and the second one looks like a logo for a straight to dvd, lame action movie. This is meant to represent a serious,official, government department and they needed a photo shoot to get those image! Criminals must be giggling all the way to their next bank robbery.
4. Ian
3 December 2009 at 2:46 PM
I agree with all the previous posts above. Metaphor or even the simple use of the acronym "ERT" using an effective and uniquely drawn letter form would be vastly superior to this comic rendition. Although I did like the campaign as shown on their web site.
5. Bubba
7 December 2009 at 12:15 PM
I think the campaign was developed before the brand was, it works well in context to the campaign but on it's own it's not very strong, considering it is part of the Vancouver Police Services. It would have been better off with just a strong type treatment, as the silhouettes will be difficult to read at a distance and you want people to instantly know that it is ERT and not second guess as most of their interaction with the public will be in stressful situations you want to be easily recognized. And yes the previous logo did look like a sports team badge.
6. Juju
8 December 2009 at 12:56 PM
Interesting ideas, executed poorly.
7. David
7 January 2010 at 11:15 PM
Subplot did this? Wow...I would have expected something better coming out of that studio. What happened here? Most flaws have been raised in the previous comments...and I agree.

Name:
Anonymous
Your Name Please!

Comment:
Editor's note: We reserve the right to edit and/or delete comments that we consider inappropriate, defamatory or malicious. Keep your comments constructive.
Comment Copy Please!

Click to refresh
Please fill in the 4-character Captcha!
Archives
Most Recent Comment
Anonymous says:
I am not sure about this as a long-term business venture. I can't see anyone wanting to put up giant...
Fontest
 
 
Calling all typophiles! Enter our font contest and you could win a prize
FREE Subscription

January/February 2012

FREE Newsletter

Sign up now for our free news and jobs email bulletin

Live from Twitter